To Close or Not to Close: Navigating Incident Management and Root Cause Analysis

by Arnab Posted on August 8, 2024 | 5 minutes read

---

---

---

Closing Incident Tickets Before Solving the Root Cause: The Right Approach for ITSM

Ever been caught in the middle of a debate about whether to close an incident ticket before fully addressing the root cause? If so, you're not alone. This question has puzzled many IT professionals and service desk teams, and navigating the best practice can be a tricky endeavor. In this article, we'll dissect the intricacies of incident management versus problem management and provide a clear, actionable guide to handling these scenarios effectively.

The Dilemma: To Close or Not to Close?

Imagine this: You’re managing a service desk and have just resolved an incident. The system is back up, and everything seems to be functioning smoothly. However, the root cause analysis (RCA) is still pending, and a problem ticket has been created to dig deeper into why the issue occurred in the first place. Now the question arises—should you close the incident ticket now or wait until the problem ticket is resolved?

This isn’t just an academic debate; it’s a real-world challenge that impacts service delivery, customer satisfaction, and operational efficiency. Let's dive into the details to find out the best approach.

Understanding the Roles: Incident vs. Problem Management

Before we delve into the specifics, it's crucial to differentiate between incident management and problem management:

Incident Management: The primary goal is to restore normal service operation as quickly as possible with minimal disruption. Incidents are typically resolved once the immediate issue is addressed, even if the underlying cause is still unknown.

Problem Management: This focuses on identifying and addressing the root cause of incidents to prevent recurrence. It involves conducting a thorough analysis to ensure that similar issues do not arise in the future.

The Case for Closing Incidents Early

1. Focus on Service Restoration

The primary goal of incident management is to quickly restore service. Once the service is back online and the customer is no longer impacted, the incident can be considered resolved from a service delivery perspective. Closing the incident at this point ensures that your service desk metrics reflect a successful resolution and maintains SLA compliance.

2. SLA and Performance Metrics

If an incident is resolved but left open while the root cause analysis continues, it can negatively impact your service desk's SLA metrics. For instance, if your SLA is based on response and resolution times, an open ticket can skew these metrics and reflect poorly on your team’s performance.

3. Customer Satisfaction

From the customer’s perspective, the incident is resolved when they no longer experience the problem. Closing the ticket once the service is restored aligns with their expectation and can lead to higher satisfaction rates. Keeping an incident ticket open while problem management is ongoing might lead to confusion or dissatisfaction if the customer thinks the issue is unresolved.

The Case for Keeping Incidents Open

1. Comprehensive Resolution

In some scenarios, it might be beneficial to keep the incident open until the problem ticket is resolved. This approach ensures that the incident and problem are tracked as a unified process, and any changes or updates from the problem management can be directly communicated to the incident ticket.

2. Continuous Monitoring

If the resolution is temporary or if there’s a risk of the issue recurring, keeping the incident open allows for ongoing monitoring. This ensures that any further complications are immediately addressed and that the problem management process can be informed of any new developments.

3. Documentation and Tracking

Keeping the incident open until the problem ticket is resolved helps in documenting the entire lifecycle of the issue. This can be valuable for historical data analysis, reporting, and ensuring that all related activities are tracked comprehensively.

Best Practices for Managing Incidents and Problems

1. Implement Clear Policies

Develop and document clear policies for when and how to close incidents in relation to problem management. These policies should be communicated to your service desk team and should outline scenarios where closing an incident early is acceptable versus situations where it is not.

2. Utilize Automation

Leverage your ITSM tool’s automation capabilities to link incidents and problems. For instance, you can set up triggers that automatically update or close incidents when certain conditions are met in the problem management process.

3. Regularly Review and Adjust

Regularly review your incident and problem management processes to ensure they are effective and aligned with your organization’s goals. Be open to adjusting policies based on feedback from your team and stakeholders.

4. Communicate Effectively

Ensure that there is clear communication between your service desk and problem management teams. Effective communication helps in keeping everyone informed about the status of incidents and related problems, ensuring a smoother transition and resolution process.

5. Focus on Customer Impact

Always keep the customer experience at the forefront. If an incident is resolved and the customer is no longer affected, closing the ticket promptly aligns with customer expectations and maintains service efficiency.

Conclusion: Finding the Balance

The question of whether to close an incident ticket before resolving the root cause is not one-size-fits-all. The best approach often depends on your organization’s policies, the nature of the incident, and the impact on customers. By focusing on service restoration, maintaining clear policies, and leveraging automation, you can navigate this dilemma effectively.

Ultimately, the goal is to balance operational efficiency with customer satisfaction. By understanding the roles of incident and problem management and implementing best practices, you can ensure a smooth, effective process that benefits both your team and your customers.

---

---

Topics to Explore: